The Case of the Singing Bridge

When I bought my first house, the first night I slept there, I was convinced the place was possessed. The first night I slept in my current house, a Nor'easter came along and the place howled like a banshee. Which brings us to the Case of the Singing Bridge.

My first house, it turned out, was not possessed. At least not by ghosts. Instead, it was being frequented by squirrels in the attic. I gently shooed them away, and plugged a hole. Case closed.

My current house involved a little more sleuthing. It turned out that railings on the balcony had been adorned with stainless steel wire cables tightly stretched between the posts. When a strong wind hit them just right, they resonated, and begin to howl. Mitigation was simple: removing the steel cables on the exposed and predominantly windward side of the house. Case closed.

The Case of the Singing Bridge involves one of the most iconic bridges in the world, the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco Bay. The problem, like so many problems, stems from an improvement. To help protect the bridge against high wind force, it was decided that better airflow through the structure was needed. So, the thick metal slats of the west handrail were replaced by thinner railing slats, chosen because of their lowered wind resistance. And that has created a very audible problem. When a strong wind hits the handrail, it really sings. There are a plethora of videos on this. Here is a local news report. And here's another video with a good audition of the singing.

The reaction of local officials was – um, predictable. According to the news report, they say the singing was “expected” and is not a bug; rather, it is a “feature.” It is certainly a very public feature. With a strong wind, San Francisco residents reported they could hear the sound inside their homes, miles away from the bridge. Some people found the sound to be trippy, or even pleasantly meditative. Other residents, the ones covering their ears, not so much. That was when the railing modification was about 75% complete; no word on the “expected” loudness level upon full completion. According to a Bridge District spokesperson, the new design is necessary to keep the bridge safe and no mitigation is planned. Like it or not, case closed.

Thus the sound of the singing bridge will likely to be a permanent albeit infrequent occurrence in San Francisco. Yes, the howling might be weirdly soothing for some people; perhaps on windy days, it will be a tourist attraction. Personally, maybe because I am abnormally bothered by distracting noises, I think it would be pretty annoying. On the other hand, maybe it will keep the squirrels away.

COMMENTS
jeffhenning's picture

The Tacoma Narrows was nicknamed "Galloping Girdy" because the winds could cause it to sway.

Then, one day, the wind came howling at just right angle at just the right sustained speed and it caused a longetudinal resonance in the bridge that became out of phase between the two sides. The hours of wind caused violent twisting that eventually tore it apart.

As to the Golden Gate, I'm sure that the few people near the bridge could find it annoying, but people stating that they can hear the bridge miles away is total crap.

Given that the bridge runs almost exactly north to south, no one toward either end will hear much of this since the bridge will act as giant line source. You might hear it if you lived at the eastern section of the Presidio and it may be a very gentle murmur in the Marina District, but that's about it. There are not a lot of people living close to the bridge. Check out a map.

I live a half mile from commuter train tracks. When Amtrak goes blasting by, it's not very loud.

Honestly, I can't see how a gentle drone note caused be the wind is really going to be that bad.

Like the Big Dig in Boston or elevated trains in Chicago, after a while you won't notice it at all.

John_Werner's picture

In a nutshell this is why all the perfect modeling in anechoic chambers sometimes fails to translate into perfect sound at home. Exciting resonances can be a huge fail. I think this is why many folks appreciate near-field point source listening.

X