Remain CALM

Are you bothered by TV commercials that seem louder than the program in which they are embedded? If so, you're not alone—the Federal Communication Commission (FCC) has received millions of consumer complaints about this, and in a rare moment of bipartisanship, the US House of Representatives passed the Commercial Advertisement Loudness Mitigation (CALM) Act last Thursday, following the Senate's unanimous passage in October. According to the reports I've read, this legislation empowers the FCC to require broadcasters to adopt industry technology—which Dolby has been working on for the last decade—that modulates sound levels and prevents overly loud commercials within one year.

Meanwhile, I wonder just how bad the problem really is. I've heard that the peak levels of commercials are no higher than those of the program content, but the dynamic range is compressed, raising the minimum level so the commercials appear to be louder. However, I haven't seen any hard data to support that assertion.

To find out for myself, I decided to take some measurements. Using my trusty Larson Davis Model 700 recording SPL meter, I set the microphone in the middle of my home theater and measured the maximum and minimum RMS levels (A weighting, slow response) in 1-minute intervals during The Simpsons Christmas Special, which aired last Sunday. The results are depicted in the graph above—the blue bars are the maximum levels in each interval, and the pink bars are the minimum levels. The yellow-shaded regions are the commercial segments, while the unshaded regions represent the program. (Thanks to Photoshop maven Joanna Cazden for her help with the graph.)

As you can see, maximum levels in the commercial segments were no higher than those in the program segments, as expected. Also, the minimum levels in the first commercial segment were indeed higher than surrounding program regions, but this distinction is much less obvious in the other two commercial segments. Interestingly, the lowest maximum level occurred during the second commercial segment, not during the program.

Of course, this is only one sample, and I intend to do many more such measurements to see if there is any objective basis for the consumer complaints and subsequent congressional action. Meanwhile, there's always the mute button or fast forwarding through commercials on DVR recordings, both of which are SOP in my home theater.

Share | |
Jarod's picture

Scott you did an outstanding job with this little experiment! The results are very interesting and intriguing! I am actually a bit surprised that this bill was passed but more surprised that they didn't make a standard for commercial volume in the beginning. I personally find that when I hear a difference in volume in commercials, be it an increase or decrease, it is when the commercials switch between local and national broadcast commercials. But like yourself, my wife and i are free of this minor inconvenience by simply DVR-ing almost everything we watch on satellite.

David Vaughn's picture

Jarod is correct. It's the local commercials that are the worst, specifically on the cable channels. This isn't as big of an issue on network shows (from my experience).

lily_03's picture

The FCC says that the single biggest criticism it receives is about the exceedingly loud sound of ads on TV and radio. How annoying is it to just get the baby to sleep only to have it awakened by a blisteringly noisy commercial? On December 13th the CALM law went into impact. Under that law, it is a federal breach for broadcasters, cable operators and satellite providers to have the volume up too high during advertisements. Source of article: CALM law keeps the volume down during commercials

Enter your Sound & Vision username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.