Do All Blu-ray Players Perform the Same?

Got a tech question for Sound & Vision? Email us at AskSandV@gmail.com

Q I am in the market for a new 3D player and have been looking at the Oppo 103 and 103D.  But the various online forums I’ve visited all say that there is hardly any picture quality difference between the Oppos and other Blu-ray players like those from Sony and Panasonic. Is that true? —Joe Montanez / via email

A It’s true that the vast majority of Blu-ray players deliver excellent baseline high-def picture quality. It’s only when you start to dive into the fine points of player performance that you’ll start to see differences between various models.

For a quick overview of those differences, check out the Video Test Bench section of Sound & Vision’s Blu-ray player reviews. We routinely run tests for video clipping (loss of information at the extreme high and low ends of the brightness range), luma resolution (black-and-white detail), and chroma resolution (color detail). Most players that have been reviewed recently sailed through those tests without a hitch. Where a few have tripped up, however, is on tests that evaluate a player’s ability to deinterlace 480i video on DVD and 1080i video on Blu-ray for 1080p output. Even if a player fails one or more of those tests, however, it still may perform perfectly fine with real-world content like movies or concert videos.

Another, equally important, point to consider when it comes to Blu-ray player picture quality is video processing features like noise reduction and detail enhancement. The bigger your display, the greater the chance you’ll notice artifacts such as compression noise or picture softness. Dealing with those PQ shortcomings is where a model like the Oppo BDP-103, which features a Marvell Qdeo video processor, has an edge over the competition. And the Darbee processor in the BDP-103D is a unique picture-enhancement feature that’s not found in any other player. (Read Kris Deering’s review of the BDP-103D to learn more about the benefits of Darbee processing.)

Lastly, certain Blu-ray players, the Oppo BDP-103 and 103D included, offer 4K upconversion. If you own, or plan to own, a 4K TV, this feature could also be a deciding factor since the player might do a better job of scaling Blu-ray and DVDs to 4K resolution than the TV itself. So to circle back, the answer is yes, there is little difference to be seen when comparing most Blu-ray players—but only when they are playing high-quality movie transfers on Blu-ray disc. However, other performance-related features do exist that can set certain models apart from the pack.

Share | |
COMMENTS
sathishdht's picture

I have the Bluray, Apple TV, Cablebox, Game Console all go through the AVR with QDEO processing enabled. It does a very good job of enhancing the SD quality to a better one. Note though none of these players or video processors and magically turn a bad quality source video to good one. So with my Panny BR player, I get excellent quality video like Online Stuff, DVDs etc upscaled. For BR, I can select source direct and bypass the AVR processing.

chrisheinonen's picture

Though it's far harder to test for and verify, some players also output the incorrect data over HDMI while others are bit perfect. For example, Sony used to have a bug but they've fixed it and are accurate now. Oppo has always been correct, most Samsung players do RGB incorrectly and other players have various other quirks. So beyond video processing, some also have issues in outputting the correct values over HDMI.

WALTER ANDRADE CARNEIRO's picture

I have three Blu-ray players: Panasonic BDT-300U, SONY BDP-S550 and OPPO BDP-103. I recently sent an email to OPPO Digital wondering why I could not see differences in picture quality of BD and DVD on the OPPO 103 compared to the other two devices, SONY and Panasonic. They answered me that these other two players also have video quality as good as the OPPO 103, with which I agreed, because differences, I believe, are only identified in the test bench as the team of Sound & Video usually publish. But I noticed that the OPPO 103 has a lot of another features that are absent on competitive devices for their price range, such as converting video from PAL to NTSC system, very useful to visualize European videos released, example: Midnight Tango, the latest BD from Robbie Williams, and two B. D. from Cliff Richard.

David Vaughn's picture
Another reason to buy and Oppo is their service is the best in the business, bar none. I doubt you would get a response as quick from Sony or Panasonic, and they would most likely not be as honest with you regarding the quality of their video output versus their competitors.
stodgers's picture

Oppo is terrific in their response time, and in the quality of the service. Having come from a Panasonic player which was bricked by one of their updates, I can honestly say that no one should buy Panasonic and expect 'service'.

X
Enter your Sound & Vision username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
Loading
setting var node_statistics_112266 setting var node_statistics_112266