Rent the Right One Now: 20 Underrated Halloween Movies Page 3

Trick 'R Treat (Warner Bros.)

A perfect alternate to the tried and true Creepshow, Trick 'R Treat is a cult classic of the truest kind. Criminally neglected a theatrical run, it will have you rethinking your prejudices around the term "straight to DVD." A series of Halloween-themed vignettes starring the likes of Anna Paquin (True Blood), Brian Cox (Manhunter), and Dylan Baker (Happiness), it's darkly funny and truly nail-biting. You'll never blow out a Jack O'Lantern again.