Rent the Right One Now: 20 Underrated Halloween Movies Page 15

Witchfinder General (Odeon)

There is no shortage of campy Vincent Price performances to be found this time of year, but why not seek out something a little more meaty from the Master of the Macabre? Price plays it straight, and sinister, in this 1968 tale of a sadistic 17th century witch-hunter. Moody, and full of creepy details, this movie not only beats the hell out of the umpteenth retelling of the Salem Witch Trials, it'll put your girlfriend's "sexy witch" costume in an uncomfortable new light.