Contrast Ratio

I hate contrast ratio. It's a stupid and pretty much useless measurement. It's up there on the list with horsepower as a useless number that tells you next to nothing about actual performance. "My SUV has 300 horsepower!" yeah, and a 0-60 time pushing double digits. Congratulations. Hmm, bad example. 0-60 is a useless number too, but that's a different conversation.

Full on/full off contrast ratio, at least as far as we do it, is measured with a 100-IRE field and a 0-IRE field only after the display has been calibrated. The most notable reason why contrast ratio is a useless statistic is that you can only compare this number to other displays we've measured. There is no set way to measure contrast ratio, so everyone else's numbers are going to be different. But even take our own numbers. When are you ever going to see, or need to see, the difference between a full white screen and a completely black screen? Oh, right. Isn't that why there's ANSI contrast ratio?

ANSI contrast ratio has eight black boxes and eight white boxes arranged on screen in a checkerboard pattern. Even this, though, is flawed. The average picture level of a TV show or DVD movie isn't anywhere near the 50% APL that the ANSI contrast tests. Some research has shown that the APL of most TV shows is less than 20% APL.

So how about a test that uses the ANSI checkerboard, but has white boxes that are, say, 40-IRE. This would average out to an overall picture level of 20%, around what most television programs are. A realistic representation of the contrast ratio you're likely to see when actually watching the display. We could still print the black level and the light output (of course).

A good idea? Maybe. It would just barely be more useful than any of the other contrast ratio specs, as you'd still only be able to compare it to other displays we've measured. Also, how much different would it be than the numbers we already print? If you take the ANSI contrast ratio as a worst case scenario, and the full on/full off contrast ratio as a best case, you're getting a pretty good representation of what's going on with the projector. What is more useful is the black level and light output numbers anyway.

Of course, this doesn't solve the problem of not being able to compare anyone else's numbers to ours or ours to theirs. That seems to be a problem for another time.

Share | |
COMMENTS
ChrisWiggles's picture

Your comments about on/off contrast are flat wrong. on/off CR in *addition* to ANSI on/off CR combine to give you the performance in instantaneous (in-scene) CR across various APL. At low APL, on/off CR is hugely important, at high APL ANSI CR is hugely important. Your blog entry has been linked to AVS forum, which is what brought this to my attention. Your tirade against on/off CR is misinformed and will profoundly misinform your readers. I hope you will withdraw your entry or correct it.

Geoffrey Morrison's picture

You

ChrisWiggles's picture

I'm sorry if I "missed the point" in your statements, but the on/off CR number is anything but useless. Yes, some on/off CR numbers are meaningless when done inaccurately or manipulated by manufacturers, but good on/off CR numbers are important because on/off CR itself is fundamentally important." the point is you can

ChrisWiggles's picture

What is more important is the actual black level and light output numbers, in foot-lamberts or lumens or whateverThis is silly to me. You can't measure the "black level" of a projection display because *that's* a meaningless quantity: it depends on screen size, gain etc. Rather, that's why we use light output, which you can figure out foot lamberts for your screen, then on/off CR gives you your black level. These two specs give you so much information, it seems very bizarre that you would suggest measuring black level and white level for one specific system which gives you the information in so much more complicated a way, and further it hinges on your ability to accurately measure the black level at the screen which is often not possible.A checkerboard at 40IRE is likewise less useful than 100IRE standard ANSI checkerboard, because anything less than 100IRE and the measurement hinges on the gamma. So it seems to me you are advocating using profoundly *less* useful measures than we have now.

ChrisWiggles's picture

And then there are statements like these in your original posting, which really mislead your readers:"When are you ever going to see, or need to see, the difference between a full white screen and a completely black screen? Oh, right. Isn't that why there's ANSI contrast ratio? "When are you ever going to look at a checkerboard in real video either? Or gray fields for grayscale? This is a hugely misleading statement, and horribly dangerous because readers will come away thinking that ANSI is somehow better a measure than on/off when they are two *completely different* measurements! I shouldn't have to explain to you why accurate and linear grayscale is important, nor why on/off CR is important, nor why ANSI CR is important, and why they're all very different things, and why all of them use completely "useless" images that we'll never see in real life. You never listen to frequency sweeps in music either, but you wouldn't claim such a ridiculous thing that FR is a "useless statistic."

Geoffrey Morrison's picture

The problem here is that we

Geoffrey Morrison's picture

Also, I was hoping this would provoke some spirited debate. It

ChrisWiggles's picture

Then I guess I don't really get your point. In measuring a projector, you're measuring a projector not a screen. Measuring footlamberts off the screen is a very strange thing to do rather than just lumens off the projector, on/ff, and ANSI. You can do all that with no screen at all. Why complicate things by inserting a screen into the equation. With these 3 specs, you can calculate white level and black level with any screen you want. Otherwise, basically you're just making it more complicated than it needs to be. If all I have is footlambert measurements, I need to do the reverse calculation with the screen information to get my lumens and on/off numbers, and then go to a screen of my choice. This seems irrationally complex.

ChrisWiggles's picture

(sorry, wordy!)If there's any 3 fundamentally important measurements here with regards to light (disregarding color for a moment), there's nothing that gives you more information than 1)lumens 2) on/off CR and 3) ANSI CR. You can calculate everything from these. You can even calculate what a checkerboard at *any* IRE will look like if you also have gamma, which would need to be measured to compare a checkerboard of anything other than 100IRE anyway, for that to have more than isolated relevance to a single display.So there is really nothing in my opinion that gets away from the importance of these fundamental measurements. Yes, there are other things that are also interesting to measure in addition to these, but there is no way that I could ever accept an argument that on/off CR or ANSI CR are unimportant. The only exception is where on/off CR is infinite, in which case it is not on/off CR that has lost importance, rather bothering to measure/quantify infinity loses relevance.likewise, thanks.

jimed1's picture

So then, what is most important, contrast ratio, or black level? I think a lot of the public conception is that in order to decern the details in dark/shadowy scenes, a televisions CR must be high. I for one also thought that this was also directly related to the tv's ability to produce blacker blacks. So when I am looking at the new RPTV's, I take note of the contrast ratio because I am assume the higher the CR, the better the black level will be. Am I wrong? Until recently, I didn't think the blacks on any of the mirco-display RPTV's was very good. The newer sets seem to be able to show black a lot better.

dezra hall's picture

I AM ABOUT TO PURCHASE MY FIRST HDTV IN ABOUT A 32" SIZE MODERATE PRICE RANGE AND HAVE BEEN COMPARISON SHOPPING FOR ALMOST 6 MONTHS BUT AM STILL CONFUSED. IS 800:1 CONTRAST RATIO GOOD ENOUGH OR DO I NEED 1000:1, 3000:1, OR MAYBE 4000:1. THANKS, ROOKIE, DEZRA

HFtD8EEpNW's picture

u2AnGw09vd JEcQAUSegAW zLfN0n12e9oy

Anonymous's picture

bibliographies?lashes milks?pet causing ambassadors

<Name>'s picture
<Name>'s picture
<Name>'s picture
Pete's picture

Well after reading all your blogs i'm still confused, can anyone tell me if the new 40" F86 Samsung is any good, it states a 2500:1 contrast ratio. Was thinking of getting one but not sure now.ThanksPete

Pete's picture

Well after reading all your blogs i'm still confused, can anyone tell me if the new 40" F86 Samsung is any good, it states a 2500:1 contrast ratio. Was thinking of getting one but not sure now.ThanksPete

Brandon Nelson's picture

Thanks you idiots asking "is this tv with with this contrast ratio better than this one?". You just ruined the whole intellegent discussion that was going on. Nobody will answer your questions. The best thing you can do is visually look at the tv's but not before reading carefully this whole page.

Shannon's picture

I give up! I am not even going to buy a tv now! Thanks a lot!

Guest's picture

earnest

hjqha's picture


The digital era, the endless variety of products and continuously updated constantly, for the people's life has brought more material to enjoy. You want to have a fashionable on the special unique products? ?Eyes you want to become a The stars? ?That as soon as possible to buy one, , MP4,it, it will bring you you want.
player in the sound quality has very good performance, small size and portability and price relatively cheap to win a lot of consumers of all ages. MP3 read the article on the issue, are generally supported TXT text to read, copy documents into the TXT on the line, but also some support for E-BOOK, as long as the MP3 file format support, copied to the MP3, you can see.Now with the continuous improvement of people's living standards, more and more digital products used in people's lives, such as MP3, MP5, but also with the price of its popular, and becoming increasingly cheaper, Here, friends can enjoy the most preferential

hjqha's picture

The digital era, the endless variety of products and continuously updated constantly, for the people's life has brought more material to enjoy. You want to have a fashionable on the special unique products? ?Eyes you want to become a The stars? ?That as soon as possible to buy one, , MP4,it, it will bring you you want.

aa's picture

The miraculous railway Tibet Tour now closely connects mainland China and remote Tibet Travel, which will speed up economic development Tour in Tibet. Travel to Tibet The Tibet Railway will not only bring about Tibet Trekking a significant change of the mystical view of the outside world to Tibet Map, but will also create a better cognition of the Tibetan people by the outside world.Tibet Tour Guide There is a strong belief that Tibet will welcome a better tomorrow thanks to this widely hailed sacred road.Want to go to Tibet tour? You can rely on us!We are offering Tibet tours in great discount,We offer Packages: popular Tibet Tour Packages, Tibet Adventure Travel Packages,Tibet Tours of all kinds.We can also customize your tour to tibet.

Anonymous's picture

123

Mauri Shoes,Gucci Shoes,D&G Shoes,Prada Shoes,Nike Air Yeezy's picture

Website: www.gobizshoes.comMSN/Email: gobizshoes@hotmail.comPayment: Paypal and Western Union.We are premium member of diytrade.com, we are a professional company dealing specially with the export of brand shoes/clothes/jeans/bags/etc.for example,Nike (jordan1-23/Air forth one/air max/air shox/dunk)...Puma,Adidas,Prada.Gucci,Timberland.Bape series shoes;Bape,BBC,LRG series t-shirt and hoody;Coogi,Evisu,red monkey,bbc,bape jeans;LV,Gucci,Burberry series bags,NBA-NFL-MLB Jersey,Chanel,LV,Aramni sunglasses;watch,hat,Golf Products and other sports products etc.you can visit our visit our webpage to review them.

shoesseller's picture

Nike,Jordan,Air force 1 sneaker - We supply brand shoes (air max, jordan,nike shox,adidas, af1, bape, dunk, iceream, puma, timberland, etc), bags, jeans,t-shirt.website: www.shoesseller.com

shoesselling's picture

Nike,Jordan,Air force 1 sneaker - We supply brand shoes (air max, jordan,nike shox,adidas, af1, bape, dunk, iceream, puma, timberland, etc), bags, jeans,t-shirt. website: http://www.shoesselling.com

Sheriff's picture

I found your site on google, great site, keep it up. Will return in the future. Submitted this post to Google News Reader. Please come visit my site sheriff office when you got time.

libraries's picture

You got a really useful blog I have been here reading for about an hour. I am a newbee and your success is very much an inspiration for me. I would love some feedback on my site public libraries when you got time.

Pages

X
Enter your Sound & Vision username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
Loading
setting var node_statistics_86266