AVR Choices

My girlfriend and I just moved into a new home, and I get to upgrade my system! I'm looking to pick up the new Panasonic TC-P55VT50 plasma, Oppo BDP-93 Blu-ray player, and the RSL 5.1 speakers. Now, I need to choose an A/V receiver to get the best out of the equipment listed above. For reference, I'm looking at the Marantz SR7005 or the Anthem MRX 500 or 700. I want something that will give the best audio and video quality; I don't care about the extra crap I won't use anyway. If any of these would be perfect, or you can think of any other great solutions (even separates), I would really like your opinion.

Aaron Dragoon

Congrats on the move and the opportunity to upgrade your system! We haven't reviewed the VT50 yet, but Tom Norton just finished his review of the less-expensive ST50, giving it Top Picks status. (That review will be in the July 2012 issue of Home Theater magazine.) And last year's VT30 was excellent, so I'd say the VT50 is a safe bet. Without doubt, the Oppo BDP-93 (reviewed here) and RSL 5.1 speaker system (reviewed here) are both superb choices.

As for the AVR, I think you can't go wrong with any of the models you mention. We reviewed the Marantz SR7005 here and the Anthem MRX 700 here, but we haven't reviewed the MRX 500, though I would expect it to be similar to the 700 in most respects. (The 700 is rated at 120 watts per channel, while the 500 is rated at 100Wpc; both have seven channels of amplification.)

The Marantz uses Audyssey MultEQ XT room correction, while the Anthems use the company's proprietary Anthem Room Correction (ARC). Both are highly regarded, though I think ARC would get the nod from many listeners. In our measurements, the Marantz handily beat the Anthem in terms of power output—especially with seven channels driven—even though they are rated nearly the same (125Wpc versus 120Wpc, two channels driven into 8 ohms). The RSLs are rated to handle 25 to 125W, so the Marantz might be a better match for them in this regard.

Video-wise, the Marantz edged out the Anthem, passing the analog video-clipping and luma-resolution tests, which the Anthem failed and got a borderline score on, respectively. (We don't recommend the Anthem if you plan to convert analog video sources to HDMI.) Both got a borderline score on the digital chroma-resolution test and failed the analog chroma-resolution test, and they both passed all other video tests.

You say you don't care about "the extra crap I won't use anyway." I'm not sure what you consider "extra crap," but the At A Glance points for the Anthem include this one: "Light on bells and whistles, heavy on high-end sound." On the other hand, as discussed above, the Marantz wins a head-to-head comparison in most respects, and it's $400 less expensive.

The only other AVR I might recommend in a similar price range is the Pioneer Elite SC-57 ($2100, reviewed here). Our measurements indicate it delivers more power than the Marantz—though not too much for your speakers—and it passes all video-processing tests except standard-definition 2:2 and chroma resolution when converting component to HDMI.

In the end, it comes down to personal taste, which I can't advise you about. If possible, try to listen to each of these with the same speakers—ideally, the RSLs—to find the one that sounds best to your ears. As I said earlier, I think you can't go wrong with any of them.

If you have an A/V question, please send it to askhometheater@gmail.com.

Share | |
COMMENTS
albert26's picture

In just commented on the New Marantz's should b availible soon.
7005 has been around for 2 yrs, A starts the alphebet,,
what about Denon/ Rotel/ NAD//ck last months Stereophile ,Rotel vs
all AAAAAAAAAA's.
lol
Brian www.Floridahometheatersplus.com

Darren gum's picture

Hi Scott
In a number of replies you mention meassured 7 channel power output and that the Marantz has greater 7 channel output. YOu also mention speaker power ratings which are generally meaningless. I think the 2channel power output and sound quality is far more important then the 7 channel output. Are there any times at which all channels would draw full power.I think most homethearthers will have the surrounds crossed over or bass limited and not run full range. And if run full range all channels most receivers steer the bass to the sub and front L R and not to the surrounds. Also to state the continuous output. How much music or movies actually have continuous output. From my experience and calculations the surround channels would always be 6db down on front channels, assuming 100watts at the front that would mean 25 for the surrounds.
Darren

mailiang's picture

I think you make a good point. However, just to clarify, all frequencies below the crossover point, (which is often recommended to be 80hz on a good system), will be directed to ALL speakers set to LARGE, including the surrounds, not to the sub, unless you set the mains to large and the sub to the plus (or LFE and mains) mode. Setting all speakers to small and directing all the bass below the crossover frequency to the sub, would significantly reduce the load on the AVR.

Ian

albert26's picture

Ian,,you r right,I like your'e style.& the crossover on the subwoofer also should b set no higher than 75,,,and use an RG6
with RCA compressions to sub ,cheaper & sounds better than any
Monster or whatever RCA interconnect!

LordoftheRings's picture

You should also include the Onkyo TX-NR3009 A/V receiver.
It has Audyssey MultEQ XT32 and is Audyssey MultEQ Pro Ready.

Plus the video processing is top notch as well.
And the overall sound quality and build is at the very top of its price range, so the value reflects your exact desire.

Cheers,
Bob

JBict65's picture

Personally, I would consider the Cambridge Audio Azur 650R AV receiver. This unit does not offer anything that I would consider 'crap' (I know exactly what you mean by that!) but if the quality of the sound is what is most important to you, this fits the bill to a t. It, to me, absolutely blows everything out of the water in terms of receiver sound. The only thing that has come as close for me are separates. However, why spend the extra money on those, let alone filling up a bunch of extra space, when this machine will make your speakers sing. Def. worth a listen!

X
Enter your Sound & Vision username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
Loading
setting var node_statistics_98861